Chamber of Secrets is my least favorite book of all the Harry Potter books.  Now I can see the importance of the book in the overall story but at the time I read it it seemed to me to be a typical second book of a series.  The heroes go and fight the same villain that they fought in the first book and beat him again but in a slightly different way.

Also, who tries to get rid of a book by flushing it down the toilet?  Even Muggles know better than that!  Of course, you can flush yourself down the toilet to get to the Ministry of Magic so maybe that isn’t such a crazy thing in the wizarding world.

And, they need a better janitor at Hogwarts.  How long has that toilet been overflowing without being fixed?  That’s just wasting water.  (I wrote a line about the water bill being horrendous and then had a whole mental discussion with myself about Hogwarts probably having wells or drawing water from the lake.  What does it say about me if I am mentally diagramming the plumbing system of a fictional world.)

This is one of the few instances where I liked the movie better than the book.  Seeing it on screen made me appreciate the book more than I had before.  I was surprised by that.

4 Replies to “Harry Potter Re-read – Chamber of Secrets”

  1. Very interesting post. I loved Chamber of Secrets myself. This is my first time through and I don’t read many series, so that could make a difference. Still, I understand your criticisms. I am not terribly fond of Hermione, so the fact that she got frozen had me smiling for a good portion of the book. I’m easy to please. LOL!

  2. LOL. You make some excellent points, especially about plumbing. And I suppose that it IS a typical second book, though that never bothered me much. Maybe it would have more if she hadn’t tied the diary (horcrux) into the ultimate ending of the series. Because of that, it felt like it was really thought out, just her introducing us to the concept early on, even if she didn’t fully explain it at this point. I did really like the film as well, though. 😀 Great post! Here’s mine!

What Do You Think?